Tilly's Tea Room in Indiana

"We had had tea at Tilly's when they were located in Saks and we were looking forward to trying it at the new location. The venue is sleek and contemporary, which may or may not appeal to others. We really liked the option of ordering the afternoon tea and sharing the tier for an additional charge of $12. They provided a pot of tea for each person and a scone. I also liked that they had the option of purchasing additional tea sandwiches. They offer egg salad can cucumber and then have some other options from which to choose including chicken salad, ham and cheese, tomato with cheese and pesto, and a salmon option. The toppings for the scones included lemon curd, a jam and clotted cream, all which were excellent. The scone was decent. The sweets included a delicious tart and a bread pudding, layered bar, and a filled chocolate. It was a good selection of teas and they were excellent. It would have been nice to have had a listing of the tease rather than have the server list them off. All in all, we had a wonderful afternoon of tea and goodies! Service was excellent. If you're looking for a more traditional tea room this location will not fit the bill. However, the price point is excellent and I would definitely return again."

"Tilley's Tea Room has set the bar for a classic tea service for 20 years. Her new location is beautiful and convenient. This is a great place for a leisurely lunch and great conversation . Holly is a fabulous hostess and makes sure everything is perfect. It's a great day for high tea!"

"Went for a baby shower at Tilly’sTea Room. The place has charm and the food was very good. I especially loved the scones and clotted cream! I highly recommend this place."

"My daughter and I went for afternoon tea. The food and tea were delicious. Holly, our server, was wonderful! She was so kind and attentive."

"We visited Tilly’s Tea Room today, and overall we would give it a 4/5. Per a previous review, it stated issues with parking. There is a parking garage connected directly to Tilly’s and it was a short 3-4 minute walk without needing to cross the usually-busy 116th street. We chose the English breakfast tea and loved it! The reviews regarding the packaged honey were in fact true. I wish it was presented in some sort of a dish with a honey stirrer just to add a little bit of a *fancier* vibe. Starting from the bottom of our tower to the top: 1. Egg salad sandwiches- 5/5 DELISH!! 2. Chicken salad sandwiches- 5/5 (this was our fave) 3. Cucumber and cream cheese sandwiches- 2/5. I wish there was more cream cheese and less cucumber- also served on white bread. That could be a personal preference, but I couldn’t take more than one bite. 4. Scones, clotted cream, lemon curd- This was a star of our meal! The scone was dense yet moist and paired beautifully with that to die for clotted cream. 5. Desserts….. 1/5. This needs some WORK. This could just totally be a preference of desserts, but these were a miss. We tried each one at least once and didn’t want to finish any of them. Overall it was a great experience and we will most likely be back! I wish there were just a couple upgrades to make it feel more luxurious (sugar cubes, honey with a stirrer, etc.). Thanks for a good time!"

"Tilly’s Tea Room is the number 1 place to get tea in all of America! They have endless flavors of tea! I recommend Share an Afternoon Tea with a Friend, it’s less expensive than Afternoon Tea, but it’s perfect for 2 people. You get a tea tower with sandwiches of your choice, mini desserts, and scones with whipped butter and daily jam. It’s great for a girl’s day out."

"Tilly’s Tea Room is an absolute gem! The atmosphere is charming and elegant—perfect for a relaxing afternoon or a special occasion. The tea selection is incredible, with beautifully brewed options that pair perfectly with their freshly made scones, sandwiches, and pastries. The wine and dinner menu is delectable with so many options!!! The staff are genuinely warm, attentive, and go above and beyond to make you feel welcome. Every detail—from the vintage decor to the delicate china—adds to the experience. Highly recommend for anyone who loves a proper afternoon tea done right or a glass of wine with a charcuterie board!!"

"Absolutely blown away by this place. The food was delicious and so so cute. The tea was great. Our server( didn’t catch the name but said Adin on the ticket) was really accommodating. My favorite part was of course the clotted cream. Would definitely come back :)"